Key takeaways:
- EFN ships every European order from one country. You keep one stock pool and usually one VAT registration, but you pay a cross-border fee per unit and the delivery promise is longer.
- Pan-European FBA lets Amazon place your stock in several countries. Cross-border fees disappear and you get local delivery speeds, but holding stock in a country creates a VAT registration there.
- The trade is simple: per-unit fee savings against fixed annual compliance cost. Pan-EU usually starts to pay once cross-border volume is steady, not once it is occasional.
- Pan-EU also needs more units in the system, because stock is split across countries and can run out locally.
- Start with EFN, prove demand in two or three marketplaces, then move to Pan-EU or Multi-Country Inventory when the numbers hold.
The short answer
Use EFN when you are testing European demand or shipping low volumes across borders. Use Pan-European FBA when cross-border orders are steady and predictable, because the per-unit cross-border fee you stop paying eventually outgrows the cost of extra VAT registrations and filings. Most brands we work with start on EFN, watch unit volume by destination marketplace for a quarter or two, then enroll.
There is a third option in between. Multi-Country Inventory lets you choose which countries hold stock. You send inventory to, say, Germany and France only, pay local fulfilment fees on those orders, and keep VAT registrations to the countries you chose. It is often the right step before full Pan-EU.
How the three programs compare
| EFN | Multi-Country Inventory | Pan-European FBA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where stock sits | One country you choose | Countries you choose | Amazon decides, across the enrolled network |
| Fulfilment fee | Local fee plus a cross-border fee per unit | Local fee in each stocked country | Local fee in the country that ships |
| VAT registrations | Usually one, in your storage country, plus OSS reporting for cross-border sales | One per country holding stock, plus OSS | One per country holding stock, plus OSS |
| Delivery promise abroad | Longer, often several days | Fast where you hold stock | Fast across the network |
| Inbound work | One shipment plan | One per stocking country | One plan, Amazon redistributes |
| Stock needed | Lowest | Medium | Highest, because units are split |
| Best for | Testing, low cross-border volume, bulky or slow movers | Two or three proven markets | Steady volume in four or more markets |
The Pan-EU network covers Germany, France, Italy, Spain, Poland and the Czech Republic, with other countries added over time. Confirm the current country list, fee schedule and enrolment rules in Seller Central before you plan around them, because Amazon changes both more often than most sellers expect.
The fee difference
EFN charges the local fulfilment fee for your size tier plus a cross-border fee for every unit shipped out of the storage country. That fee scales with size and weight. For a small, light unit it is modest. For a heavy or bulky product it can be large enough to turn an otherwise fine margin negative on every French or Italian order.
Pan-EU removes the cross-border fee. The order ships from whichever local centre has the unit, at that country's domestic fee. You still pay storage in each country, and you are now exposed to local long-term storage fee clocks in more than one place.
So the saving per unit is roughly "cross-border fee minus any difference in local fulfilment fees". Check your own numbers in the fee schedule for your size tier rather than using a rule of thumb.
The VAT difference
This is the part that stops most sellers, and it is worth being precise.
Selling cross-border to EU consumers does not by itself require a registration in the buyer's country. Since July 2021 you charge the destination country's VAT rate once your total EU cross-border B2C sales pass the €10,000 annual threshold, and you report it through the One Stop Shop return filed in one country. One registration, one quarterly return.
Holding stock in a country is different. Storage creates a local VAT obligation in that country, which means a registration, local filings and usually a local tax agent. Pan-EU puts your stock in several countries, so you take on several of those. Multi-Country Inventory does the same, but only in the countries you picked.
Treat the compliance cost as a fixed annual number: registration fees in year one, then filing fees every year after. Get a quote from a VAT agent for the exact countries before you model anything. Tax rules change, so take advice rather than our word for it.
Where the breakeven usually sits
The maths is a fixed cost against a per-unit saving.
Annual compliance cost for the extra countries, divided by your cross-border fee saving per unit, equals the units per year at which Pan-EU breaks even.
As an example only: if extra registrations and filings run around €3,000 a year and you save €2 per unit, you need about 1,500 cross-border units a year, or roughly 125 a month, to break even on fees alone. Swap in your real quote and your real fee table and the answer can move a long way in either direction. Heavy products break even much sooner. Light products may never break even on fees alone.
Fees are not the whole story. Pan-EU also improves the delivery promise on local marketplaces, and a faster promise usually lifts conversion rate. If local delivery takes your German conversion rate from 8% to 10%, that gain can matter more than the fee saving. We measure it per marketplace rather than assuming it.
The hidden cost: more stock in the system
Pan-EU splits your units across countries. Amazon decides the split. If it puts too few units in Italy, Italian orders either ship cross-border at a fee or the offer loses its fast delivery promise. Either way your cover per country is thinner than the headline number suggests.
Plan for more inventory and more cash tied up. In practice that means raising your days of cover before you enroll, not after. A regional stockout drops organic rank in that marketplace and the recovery takes weeks, the same as any other stockout.
One more operational trap: Pan-EU requires your ASINs to be enabled for FBA across the enrolled marketplaces. If a listing is inactive, suppressed or missing a compliance document in one country, Amazon may exclude that ASIN from placement and charge cross-border fees on it anyway. Check offer status per marketplace monthly.
How we decide, step by step
Read this flowchart as text
- Cross-border units per month by destination marketplace
- Steady volume in 3 or more EU markets?
- Stay on EFN test demand, fix listings
- Model fee saving per unit from the fee schedule
- Saving beats annual VAT compliance cost?
- Multi-Country Inventory two or three countries
- Stock cover and cash support a wider split?
- Raise cover first, enroll next quarter
- Enroll in Pan-EU enable ASINs in all markets
- Lower cost per unit, faster local delivery
A note on the UK
Since Brexit, UK stock and EU stock are separate pools for most sellers. A unit in a German fulfilment centre is not a free ride into a British order. Amazon offers cross-border options between the two, but customs, import VAT and duty apply, and the economics differ from intra-EU shipping. Plan the UK as its own stock decision with its own forecast.
What this means for your advertising
Do not scale ads into a marketplace before the fulfilment decision is settled. On EFN, the longer delivery promise usually suppresses conversion, which means a higher ACoS in Italy and Spain than in your home market for the same keywords. That is a logistics number, not an ad number, and cutting bids will not fix it.
Once Pan-EU is live and local delivery shows on the offer, rerun the conversion rate per marketplace before you set new ACoS targets. We usually give it two to three weeks of clean data first.
How WeSpark handles this
Frequently asked questions
Is Pan-European FBA cheaper than EFN?
Per unit, yes, because the cross-border fee disappears and the order ships at a local fulfilment rate. In total, only once your cross-border volume is high enough to cover the extra VAT registrations and filings. Below that point EFN is usually cheaper and much simpler.
Do I need a VAT number in every country for EFN?
Usually not. EFN keeps stock in one country, so you register there and report cross-border consumer sales through the One Stop Shop once you pass the €10,000 EU-wide threshold. Confirm this with a VAT adviser for your own setup, since tax rules change.
Can I use Pan-EU for some products and not others?
Enrolment is at offer level, so you can keep some ASINs out. That is a sensible approach for bulky, slow-moving or seasonal items where splitting stock across countries would create local stockouts.
How long does it take to see the benefit after enrolling?
Amazon needs time to redistribute inventory, so local delivery promises appear country by country over a few weeks. We look at conversion rate and unit volume per marketplace about three weeks after the split settles, then reset ad targets from that data.
